Directed by Christopher Nolan – Written by Christopher Nolan – Starring Matt Damon, Tom Holland, Anne Hathaway, Robert Pattinson, Himesh Patel, John Leguizamo, Samantha Morton, Charlize Theron, and Zendaya
After ten years fighting the Trojan War, Odysseus, king of Ithaca, begins a long and increasingly dangerous journey home to his wife and son.
There are a dozen different ways to talk about The Odyssey.
You can approach it as an adaptation of Homer and talk about everything Nolan changes, combines, or leaves behind. You can talk about the technical achievement of putting something this enormous on screen. Or you can dig into any number of ideas running through Odysseus’ journey.
My way into the film was through war, and what happens to the world after the fighting ends.
But before getting into all of that, this is also one hell of a movie.
It looks incredible. I don’t know how much I can add to the conversation about Nolan’s techniques, practical effects, locations, or cameras, except to say that they worked on me. I was completely transported into this world.
There’s also very little glamour to it. This has the scale of an old Hollywood sword-and-sandal epic without making the world look particularly inviting. Everything feels physical, dirty, and dangerous, and Nolan occasionally pushes the mythological elements surprisingly close to horror.
The Cyclops is genuinely frightening rather than simply a giant man with one eye. The transformations are grotesque. Hades feels like somewhere Odysseus has barely survived rather than another fantastic destination on his adventure. Those choices make the danger feel real even when the movie is dealing with gods and monsters.
Then there’s Matt Damon.I’ve always been a Damon fan. I think his celebrity sometimes makes it easy to overlook just how good an actor he is. This may be the best I’ve ever seen him. His Odysseus can be arrogant, intelligent, brutal, frightened, exhausted, charismatic, and completely broken, sometimes without the movie giving him much dialogue to explain any of it.
Damon carries an enormous amount of this film on his face, and he makes the years of this journey feel like years.
Anne Hathaway doesn’t have nearly as much screen time, but she’s excellent as Penelope. There’s a strength to her that immediately makes it clear she hasn’t simply spent twenty years waiting around for her husband to come home. She’s been running Ithaca in his absence, and one exchange with Telemachus makes that abundantly clear.
Himesh Patel is also very good as Eurylochus, especially as the relationship between Odysseus and his men begins to deteriorate. Samantha Morton brings an unsettling presence to Circe, while Charlize Theron does a lot with relatively little screen time as Calypso. She has an almost ageless quality that makes it immediately believable that Odysseus has encountered someone outside the ordinary world. John Leguizamo is solid as well, folding his usual larger-than-life charisma into a much more restrained performance.
Not everyone worked equally well for me. Robert Pattinson occasionally felt a little too broad as Antinous for a movie that otherwise pulled me so completely into its world. Zendaya is solid but isn’t given a lot to do, while Tom Holland does attempt some strong work as Telemachus but feels like he is surrounded by some serious heavyweight performances.
But as the film went on, I found myself looking at Odysseus’ journey through a particular lens — one I kept thinking about afterward.
Hospitality is treated as something sacred in this world. A stranger arrives and is given food and shelter, while the guest has obligations to the host in return. The film comes back to this again and again, referring to it as Zeus’ Law. It’s one of the basic rules holding this world together.
And Odysseus helped break it.
The Greeks win the Trojan War through deception. The Trojans accept the horse as a gift and bring it inside their walls. Odysseus and his men weaponize that trust.
What fascinated me is that Odysseus doesn’t seem to immediately understand what that victory has done. He leaves Troy still carrying himself like the victorious commander. His men are disciplined and loyal. They continue into the world expecting certain rules to apply, even though they have participated in proving that those rules can be broken.
Then, encounter by encounter, that world seems to reveal itself to them. People flee from Odysseus and his men without knowing who they are. The Cyclops becomes another violent breakdown between host and guest. The armored giants they encounter appear prepared to repel outsiders before they even arrive. Each new trial feels like another escalation. The world becomes a little more suspicious, a little more violent, and a little less governed by the rules Odysseus expects to protect him.
His own men begin changing as well. The soldiers who once trusted Odysseus enough to sit inside the Trojan Horse while some of them died around them increasingly question him. Suspicion grows. Discipline breaks down. Eventually, Odysseus can barely control the men he once commanded.
By the time they meet Circe, she has seen what men like them have done. They arrive from the sea. They steal. They pillage. They rape. From her perspective, these men aren’t the victims of a dangerous world. They’re part of the reason it’s dangerous.
And now hospitality has become a weapon, a reflection of the same kind of betrayal Odysseus helped use to win the war. This is where it feels like what Odysseus has done finally begins to dawn on him, and Damon sells that shift.
This is also where the journey feels less about how the world changes Odysseus and more about Odysseus bearing witness to the world he helped create. The consequences of war are no longer confined to the people who fought it.
After years of numbing himself and hiding from the world with Calypso, Odysseus returns to Ithaca and finds that this breakdown of hospitality has reached his home. The suitors have abused their position as guests. And to save his home, Odysseus and his son become part of that erosion of trust themselves.
That made Odysseus’ return far more complicated than simply a hero finally reaching the place he’s spent years trying to find. Ithaca may still physically be there, but the world he left behind isn’t.
And eventually Penelope helps put words to the realization Odysseus has seemingly been moving toward throughout the film.
He and the returning Greeks are the men from the sea.
I expected The Odyssey to be about how ten years of war and ten more years trying to get home changed these men. Instead, I found a film about how that war changed the world.
Every boundary crossed becomes a boundary someone else can now cross. Every atrocity becomes precedent. Every rule broken in the name of victory makes that rule a little less sacred.
By the end, I felt like I had watched Christopher Nolan use a war criminal as the main character of an anti-war story.
I loved the spectacle. I loved the performances. I was completely transported into this world. But days later, it’s the ideas that still occupy my mind.
There has already been a lot of discourse around The Odyssey, and there are so many different roads you can take when talking about this film. I’m sure there are things I missed, interpretations I would disagree with, and ideas I might see completely differently the next time I watch it.
But that’s almost beside the point.
A truly great movie doesn’t just give you something to watch. It gives you something to wrestle with after it’s over.
Verdict: True Cinema
