Written by: Richard Matheson
Directed by: Leo Penn
Starring: William Shatner, Leonard Nimoy, DeForest Kelley, George Takei, James Doohan, Grace Lee Whitney
A transporter malfunction creates a second version of Captain Kirk, splitting him into two very different personalities. As the duplicate becomes increasingly dangerous, the original Kirk begins losing the qualities that make him an effective captain.
Star Trek does the evil twin!
Sort of.

After an episode about a mysterious substance that causes the crew to lose their inhibitions, we now have a story about a transporter accident that literally splits Captain Kirk into two people. It’s an interesting premise, although there’s something a little funny about getting another story so soon that revolves around people behaving very differently from their usual selves. Especially this early in the series, when we’re still getting to know these characters and haven’t fully established what their usual selves are.

I am enjoying watching the show evolve. Sulu is getting a more active role, and Scotty is finally starting to get some expanded screen time. On the production side, the episode has some fun moments, although I have to feel a little bad for the dog in that homemade-looking alien costume.
The story does a good job of stacking problems on top of one another. There are members of the landing party stranded on a planet where the temperature is dropping toward subzero levels, the transporter is malfunctioning, and the duplicate Kirk is running around the ship. With night approaching and the temperature continuing to fall, the crew is working against a ticking clock to get everyone back safely. Star Trek likes to use a race against time to build tension.

There’s a more interesting idea underneath the familiar doppelganger setup. The duplicate isn’t really another Kirk so much as a piece of him, separated from the rest of his personality. Rather than simply presenting us with good Kirk and evil Kirk, the episode divides his personality between aggression and restraint. The duplicate is impulsive and aggressive, while the original Kirk becomes increasingly meek and uncertain.
It raises some philosophical questions about what makes someone who they are, and whether the traits we consider negative are also connected to some of our more positive qualities. Can you separate the worst parts of someone’s personality without also taking away some of what makes them who they are?
There’s a lot to explore in that idea, and I think it’s one of the more interesting concepts the show has introduced so far. Unfortunately, I don’t think the episode quite makes the most of it.
The story relies heavily on William Shatner playing both sides of Kirk, and the contrast between the two performances starts to wear a little thin. The distinction is sometimes so exaggerated that it becomes difficult to focus on what the story is trying to say about the nature of man.

“The Enemy Within” has an interesting premise and raises some worthwhile questions about personality, identity, and what makes someone capable of leading others. I just wish the episode had done a little more with that concept than having the duplicate Kirk shout a lot, drink brandy, and attempt to sexually assault Yeoman Rand.
Star Trek Verdict: Redshirt
