Always as Young as We’ll Ever Be is a warm blend of folk, indie pop, chamber pop and Americana that keeps returning to one idea: learning how to let go.
“Give It All Away” sets the tone with an intimate arrangement, layered guitars and banjo, and really fun harmonies that let you settle into the album easily. There’s a heartfelt message about loosening your grip on the things you can no longer control.
“Diamonds” is a really pretty song with one of the album’s strongest hooks and more gorgeous harmonies (let’s face it, they all have gorgeous harmonies). I especially love some of the guitar work. The song feels like it’s searching for beauty through the gray, with a sense of resilience underneath it.
“The Uncertain Seas” sounds like a single, blending country, folk and indie pop into something immediately catchy. It moves with so much natural momentum that listening to it makes me feel like a leaf floating down a river, accepting wherever the current takes me.
“What Is This” rolls things back into a more traditional, almost Gothic folk sound before “Tiny Rebellions” takes a dramatic turn.
“Tiny Rebellions” is darker and more expansive. The opening tension reminds me a little of Fleetwood Mac’s “The Chain” before it combusts. There’s an almost Southern-rock cry coming from the guitar in the background, a killer fiddle and drums that hit with real force. It’s a powerhouse.
“Quantum Physics” is intricate and powerful, while “Casually Getting the Job Done” moves at a steady pace and just kind of scoops you up for the ride. The vocals work beautifully together, and the whole thing sounds like it could be a hit.
“Shitty Light” is a pretty, detailed, banjo-led song about perspective and how seeing something from a different angle—or simply in better lighting—can change the way we understand it.
“Spill the Beans” has a real throwback quality. It’s a longer, denser track with a conversational feel that makes me think a little of Bright Eyes’ “Four Winds,” but without the same urgency. There’s a lot going on musically, but everything flows together so naturally.
“Thorn” closes things out with a quiet waltz and returns to the idea of letting go. But there’s still pain mixed in with the peace of that gesture. Acceptance doesn’t necessarily mean you’ve stopped being angry or hurt.
The line: “I wish you well, go to hell” captures that contradiction perfectly.
Always as Young as We’ll Ever Be spends a lot of time with uncertainty, grief, change and disappointment. It never suggests there’s some easy resolution waiting on the other side.
Instead, it searches for beauty, perspective, and grace amid life’s inevitable struggles.
And if it can’t find any of that, it tells you to go to hell.
Verdict: Good
Explore more from The Lowest Pair
Official Site | Spotify | Bandcamp
